|
Disability - Challenges Vs Responses by Ali Baquer, Anjali Sharma
Statutory Health Services
Although significant advancements have been
made in health sector during past few years, it has
failed to meet routine challenges. Repeated outbreaks of
disease like Malaria, Cholera, Dengue etc. in several
parts of the country have posed a great threat to the
wellbeing of the population. The life expectancy of
people and their changing life styles have been
increasing the rate of diseases like cancer, mental
health problems, cataract induced blindness, diabetes,
HIV/AIDs and its nexus with tuberculosis. Although health
is a State subject under the Constitution, the Department
of Health of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in
the Central Government formulates a Comprehensive Health
Plan so as to take concerted measures to combat major
communicable and non-communicable diseases.The main functions of the
Department of Health are :
- to undertake National
Health Programmes in order to intensify measures
for the prevention, control and eradication of
communicable diseases and reduce mortality and
morbidity due to all diseases;
- to promote education,
research and training in various medical
disciplines to reorient the medical colleges in
the delivery of health services in rural areas;
- to prevent
adulteration of food as well as drugs;
- to give impetus to
bio-medical research; and
- to collaborate with
member contries of United Nations &
international agencies like WHO, UNICEF in
matters relating to health promotion and
development.
The Plan outlay for
Central Sector Health Programme in the Annual Plan
199596 was Rs. 670.00 crore including a foreign aid
component of Rs. 225.00 crore. A major portion of outlay
is for the National Health Programmes for the Control of
communicable and non-communicable diseases implemented
through centrally sponsored programmes. The external
assistance has been sought to get the enhanced quantum of
funds for programmes in critical areas mainly diseases
control programme viz. leprosy, tuberculosis, AIDs and
blindness.
Another major component of the Central Sector Health
Programme is Purely Central Schemes through which
financial assistance is given to about 80 institutions.
These institutions are responsible for contribution in
the field of control of communicable and non-communicable
diseases, medical education, training, research and
patient care. During 199596 Rs. 245.00 crore
allocation have been made under Purely Central Schemes.
Financial
Assistance to Voluntary Organisations
The Government of
India have been giving financial assistance to the
Voluntary Organisations for encouraging them to set up
new hospitals/dispensaries in rural areas or to expand
and improve the existing hospital facilities. Financial
assistance is available under the following grant-in-aid
schemes :
- Scheme for
improvement of Medical Services;
- Promotion and
Development of Voluntary Blood Donation
Programme; and
- Special Health Scheme
for Rural Areas. Grants-in-aid amounting to Rs.
22.13 lakh were released to 11 voluntary
institutions during the year 199495. An
amount of Rs. 18.63 lakh has been released to 8
voluntary institutions during 199596.
Health
Ministers Discretionary Grant
Financial
assistance to the poor and indigent patients is given
from the Health Ministers Discretionary Grant to
defray a part of the expenditure on hospitalisation /
treatment in cases where free medical facilities are not
available.
During 199495 assistance totalling Rs. 9.63 lakh
was given to 104 individuals. A provision of Rs. 30 lakh
has been made during the financial year 199596. The
maximum ceiling of grant has been raised from Rs.
10,000/- to Rs. 20,000/- in each case. A sum of Rs. 29.97
lakh has been released to 257 patients during the
financial year 199596.
Medical
Relief and Supplies
Under the Central
Government Health Scheme (CGHS), a number of new
initiatives have been taken up. Expenses incurred on
Intra Ocular Lens (IOL), Hearing Aids and Pacemakers have
become reimbursable. In order to expedite disposal of
reimbursement of medical expenses claims, powers to
reimburse the cost of artifical appliances have been
delegated to the administrative Ministries/Departments.
The Additional Directors/Deputy Directors of CGHS
Organisations have also been delegated powers to
reimburse the cost of artificial appliances to the
pensioners.
National
Health Programmes
The Central
Government has taken certain steps to combat
communicable, non-communicable and other major diseases
which cause disability not only to improve the health
status of Indias population but also to prevent and
control disabilities. For this purposes, several National
Health Programmes are directly run by the concerned
ministers.
National
Leprosy Eradication Programme :
National Leprosy
Eradication Programme (NLEP) is implemented as a 100%
Centrally sponsored scheme. The aim of NLEP is to achieve
elimination of Leprosy by the year 2000 A.D. Free
treatment services with combination of drugs,
Multiple-Drug Therapy (MDT) are provided to all leprosy
patients throughout the country through trained leprosy
workers. Estimated number of persons requiring treatment
for leprosy has declined from 4 million cases in 1985 to
0.54 million cases in March, 1996. More than 6.5 million
leprosy patients have been cured with MDT and percentage
of registered patients taking MDT treatment has increased
from 10 per cent in 1985 to 96 per cent in 1996. The
prevalence rate of leprosy has declined from 57.3 per
thousand population in 1981 to 5.9 per thousand
population in 1996. Number of new leprosy cases detected
each year has remained about 0.45 million.
About 15-20 per cent children suffer with leprosy.
Proportion of infectious cases varies from 15-20 per cent
while 5 to 15 per cent patients suffer from various types
of deformities.
Currently most of the leprosy patients are in the states
of Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh and West Bengal.
Programme
Objectives :
The Government of
India launched National Leprosy Eradication Programme in
198283 with an aim to achieve elimination of
leprosy by 2000 A.D. and to reduce its prevalence to
<1/10,000 population. In order to achieve this several
strategies were adopted including :
- Early detection of
leprosy cases through health workers, trained in
leprosy.
- Provision of
domiciliary Multi-Drug Treatment (MDT) by
specially trained staff in leprosy to cover 201
districts with prevalence of 5 or more leprosy
cases per 10,000 population, by specially trained
staff in leprosy.
- Provision of MDT
Services through Mobile Leprosy Treatment Units
with the help of existing health care services in
moderate to low endemic areas/districts.
- Intensification of
health education activities; and
- Appropriate
rehabilitation.
Financial
Targets and Achievements of NLEP
- Eighth Plan
(199297) - Approved Outlay - Rs. 140.00
crore.
- Outlay and
Expenditure during Annual Plans 199293 to
199697.
| Annual Plans |
Approved Outlay Rs. in crore |
Actual Expenditure Rs. in crore |
| 1992-93 |
35.00 |
173.42 (1992-95) |
| 1993-94 |
35.00 |
|
| 1994-95 |
94.00 |
|
| 1995-96 |
80.00 |
64.53 |
| 1996-97 |
74.00 |
68.42 (Anticipated) |
| Total |
318.00 |
305.95 (Anticipated) |
- Eighth Plan (1992-97)
- Anticipated Expenditure - Rs. 305.95 crore.
- Ninth Plan
(1997-2002) - Proposed Outlay Rs. 337.04 crore of
which Foreign Aid is Rs. 294.04 crore.
- Annual Plan (1997-98)
- Proposed Outlay Rs. 82.28 of which Foreign Aid
is Rs. 75.13.
Targets
and Achievements of NLEP
| Year |
Case Detection |
Case Treatment |
Case Discharge |
| |
Target |
Achievement |
Target |
Achievement |
Target |
Achievement |
| 1992-93 |
289 |
547 |
289 |
541 |
573 |
1052 |
| 1993-94 |
265 |
494 |
265 |
486 |
525 |
719 |
| 1994-95 |
224 |
429 |
224 |
419 |
424 |
626 |
| 1995-96 |
225 |
434 |
225 |
420 |
425 |
613 |
The impact of MDT Services
has been sustantial, where MDT epidemiological impact
assessed in 40 districts, where MDT programme has been in
progress for past four or more years, shows that there is
a marked reduction in prevalence rate (approximately 85
per cent); in annual new case detection rate (30 per
cent); and deformity rate (80 per cent). The World Bank
assistance has further strengthened the programme. It is
expected that there would remain just over 100,000
leprosy cases and by the end of 2000 A.D., not more than
20,000 cases. This would bring in an effective break in
the transmission of the disease and the goal to bring it
down to less than 1 per 10,000 population set by the
World Health Organisation would be achieved year-wise.
National
Programme for Control of Blindness :
National Programme
for Control of Blindness (NCPCB) was launched in the year
1976 as a 100 per cent centrally sponsored programme.
Various activities of the programme include establishment
of Regional Institute of Ophthalmology, upgradation of
Medical Colleges, district hospitals and Block Level
Primary Health Centres, development of mobile units,
recruitment of required ophthalmic manpower in eye care
units for provision of various opthalmic services. The
goal is to reduce the prevalence of blindness from 1.4
per cent to 0.3 per cent by 2000 A.D.
The infrastructure
developed so far and targets for the year 199596
are as follows :
| Infrastructure
|
Developed /
Upgraded so far |
Services sanctioned
during 1995-96 |
| State
ophthalmic Cell |
19 |
- |
| Medical
Colleges |
81 |
1 |
| District
Hospitals |
418 |
3 |
| DMUs
|
269 |
5 |
| PHCs
|
5117 |
26 |
| Eye
Banks (Govt.) |
166 (Total) |
3 |
| Eye
Bank (Pvt.) |
- |
- |
| DBCS
|
456 |
- |
The assistance provided to
the service components under this programme has been
enhanced during 199596, with the budget allocation
raised from Rs. 40 crore during 199495 to Rs. 72
crore during the current year 199596. There is a
provision of Rs. 75 crore during 199697.
| Year |
Budget Allocated Rs. in crore |
Expenditure Reported Rs. in crore |
| 1993-94 |
25 |
19.70 |
| 1994-95 |
40 |
38.26 |
| 1995-96 |
72 |
57.51 |
| 1996-97 |
72 |
|
Performance of cataract
operations has gone up. Target for the year 199495
was 24.50 lakh and 21.56 lakh operations were performed.
A target of 26.20 lakh operations has been set for the
year 199596 and 19.73 lakh operations have been
performed so far.
Performance of Cataract
Operations
| Year |
Targets |
Achievements |
| 1992-93 |
20,00,000 |
80% |
| 1993-94 |
24,30.000 |
79% |
| 1994-95 |
24,50,000 |
88% |
| 1995-96 |
25,50,000 |
86% (upto Feb,96) |
| 1996-97 |
26,20,000 |
- |
Voluntary organisations
are playing an important role in this programme. District
Blindness Control Societies (DBCS) are being established
throughout the country under the Chairmanship of District
Magistrate/District Commissioner. Till now, about 456
DBCS have been established.
External
Assistance :
The following agencies
have been assisting (NPCB) since 1980 :
- World Health
Organisation (WHO) WHO has been assisting
NPCB in organising workshops and seminars at the
national and state levels; sponsoring fellowship
for regional and extra-regional countries;
professional development of manpower and supply
of sophisticated ophthalmic equipment.
- Danish International
Development Agency (DANIDA) In 1978, an
agreement was signed between the Government of
India and the Government of Denmark to provide
support for the development of services unde
NPCB, viz supply of equipments to Mobile Units,
Primary Health Centres and District Hospitals and
covering part of recurring costs. It is also
involved in the following activities :
- Manpower development;
- Establishment of
Management Systems at State level;
- Establishment and
development of monitoring and evaluation systems;
- Preparation of Health
Education material, teaching and information
aids; and
- Training.
- World Bank Assistance
A World Bank assisted Blindness Control
project is under implementation since
199495. The proposed expenditure of the
project is Rs. 554 crore during the project
period of 7 years.
The project is being
implemented in 7 major states of the country viz. Andhra
Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Orissa,
Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan.
Major inputs of the project are upgrading the ophthalmic
services expanding the coverage in rural and tribal
areas, establishment and functioning of DBCS, training of
ophthalmic manpower, improving the management information
systems and creating awareness about the programme in the
masses.
Under the World Bank project a sum of Rs 21 crore is
being allocated for the year 199495. Assistance of
Rs. 48.60 crore was earmarked for the year 199596.
National
Iodine Deficiency Disorders Control Programme
Iodine deficiency
manifests itself in a wide range of physical and mental
disorders, the most extreme form being hypothyroidism.
The survey conducted by the Central and the State Health
Directorates, Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR)
and Medical Institutes have clearly demonstrated that no
Indian State is free from the ill-effects of Iodine
Deficiency Disorders and an estimated 63 million in the
country have disorders attributable to this deficiency
and about 167 million are at risk.
About 54.4 million persons are suffering from endemic
goitre, about 8.8 million from mental handicap, about 2.2
million are cretins and about 6.6 million have mild
neurological disorders. The survey results indicate that
out of 255 districts surveyed, Iodine Deficiency
Disorders are a major public health problem in 222
districts.
Realising the magnitude of the problem the Government of
India launched a 100 per centrally assisted National
Goitre Control Programme (NGCP) in 1962 with the
following objectives :
- Initial surveys to
assess the magnitude of Iodine Deficiency
Disorders.
- Supply of Iodated
Salt in place of common salt; and
- Resurveys to assess
the impact of Iodated Salt every 5 years.
In August 1992, the
National Goitre Control programme (NGCP) was renamed as
national lodine Deficiency Disorders Control Programme
(NIDDCP) with a view of wide spectrum of lodine
Deficiency Disorders. On the recommendations of central
council of Health in 1984, the Government took a policy
decision to iodate the entire edible salt in the country
by 1992. The programme started in April, 1986 in a phased
manner. To date, the annual production of iodated salt in
our country is 34 lakh metric tonnes per anum.
Achievements
:
The achievements made
under the programme from its inception to date are as
under :
- The Policy of iodated
salt production has been liberalised to private
sector. 641 private manufacturers have been
licensed by the Salt Commissioner, out of which
nearly 532 units have commenced production so
far. They have annual production capacity of
iodated salt of more than 60 lakh metric tonnes
(MT) for the entire country.
- Annual production of
iodised salt has been raised from 5.0 lakh MT in
1985-86 to 35 lakh MT in 1995-96. This is
expected to be further raised to 50.00 lakh MT in
near future.
- The Salt Commissioner
in consultation with the Ministry of Railways
arranges for the transporatation of iodated salt
from the production centres to the consuming
States under priority category B, a
priority second to that for defence.
- In order to ensure
use of only iodated salt, 26 States/UTs have
completely banned the salt other than iodised
salt while three other States have issued partial
ban whereas three States have yet to issue the
ban.
- For effective
monitoring and proper implementation of National
Iodine Deficiency Disorders Control Programme,
all the States/UTs have been advised to set up
Iodine Deficiency Disorders Control Cells in the
State Health Directorates and Central Government
provide cash grants for this purpose. Presently,
25 States/UTs have established such types of
cells. The States of Goa, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu
and Kashmir, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Union Territory
of Pondicherry and Lakshadweep have not yet so
far set up such IDD Control Cells.
- For ensuring the
quality control of iodated salt at consumption
level, testing have been set at the Bio-Chemistry
division of Institute of Communicable Diseases,
Delhi for training both medical and para-medical
personnel and monitoring salt and urinary iodine.
- For ensuring the
quality control of iodated salt at consumption
level, testing kits for on the spot qualitative
testing have been developed and were distributed
to all District Health Officers in endemic States
for awareness.
- It has been proposed
to set up district level IDD monitoring labs in
all the States who have issued ban notification
complete/partial for iodine content of salt and
urinary iodine excretion which are the most
effective tools for proper implementation of IDD
Control Programme. Tentative allocation of Rs.
75,000 per lab have been provided for this
purpose.
- Cash grants are
provided by the Central Government for conducting
surveys/re-surveys of IDD; Health education and
Publicity campaign to promote the consumption of
iodated salt.
- Realising the
importance of iodine deficiency in relation of
Human Resource Development, NIDDC has been
included in 20 point Programme.
- The standards for
iodated salt have been laid down under PFA Act,
1954. These stipulate the iodine content of salt
at the production and consumption level should be
at least 30 and 15 ppm respectively, and
- GOI-UNICEF Project
1992-95 is being implemented in 13 selected
endemic States for extensive monitoring and
Information Education & Communication (IEC)
activities of National Iodine Deficiency
Disorders Control Programme. The activities are
to be strengthened in 10 selected districts of
the 13 states including North-Eastern regions.
Information,
Education and Communication (IEC) on lodine Deficiency
Disorders
To intensify IEC
activities, a communication package having the following
highlights was finalised with UNICEF:
- Radio/TV spots were
prepared and their broadcast/telecast is being
done.
- A 10 minutes video
film on Iodine Deficiency Disorders was made and
distributed to the states.
- Posters/Danglers have
been developed.
- Material for posters
highlighting the storage technique of iodised
salt for use by wholesaler and retailers has been
prepared and distributed.
National
Mental Health Programme :
The National
Mental Health Programme was launched during Seventh Five
Year Plan to ensure availability of Mental Health Care
Services for all, specially for those at risk in
under-privileged sections of the community. The basic
emphasis was on the promotion of community participation
in the Mental Health Services development as a measure of
self-help and self-reliance. The National Advisory Group
identified 11 institutions for the training of health
workers under the programme. This training consist of
imparting basic knowledge of mental health to the Primary
Health Care Physicians and Para-Medical Personnel. During
199596, Rs. 5 lakh was allocated for this
programme.
National
Filaria Control Programme :
Filariasis is a
major public health problem in many States of the country
and about 420 million people are estimated to be living
in 175 endemic districts of which about 109 million are
in urban areas of which about 47 million urban population
is being protected. The infection is transmitted through
insect bites and results in a disabling disease causing
swelling which results in tremendous enlargement of leg
or foot, or other part of the body.
The National Filaria Control Programme was launched in
1955. Under the Programme the following measures were
undertaken :
- Delimitation of the
problem in hitherto unsurveyed areas; and
- Control in urban
areas through recurrent anti-larval measures and
anti parasitic measures by 206 control units and
198 clinics, giving treatment with diethyl
carbamisine to clinical cases and microfilaria
carriers.
During the Eighth Plan
anti-filarial drugs were distributed through Primary
Health Care Delivery System in the rural areas of endemic
States.
Number of Microfilaria (Mf) carriers and disease cases
detected during the last three years by the control units
and filaria clinics are as follows :
| Year |
No. of examined |
No. of +ve for Mf |
Mf Rate % |
No. of +ve for disease |
Disease Rate % |
| 1992 |
3,736,744 |
50,492 |
1.4 |
40,262 |
1.10 |
| 1993 |
3,790,804 |
45,876 |
1.2 |
37,720 |
0.99 |
| 1994 |
3,960,013 |
47,427 |
1.2 |
35,219 |
0.89 |
Other
Major Health Programmes
The care of
mothers and children occupies a paramount place in the
Indian health services delivery system. This is reflected
from the fact that 9 out of the 17 goals listed in the
National Health Policy (1983) relate to maternal and
child health.
As an integral part of the overall strategy for reduction
of infant mortality to below 60 per thousand live births;
child mortality to below 10 per thousand under five,
child population and maternal mortality to below 200 per
100,000 live births by 2000 AD, the followling specific
programmes have been under implementation in the country
as 100 per cent centrally sponsored Family Welfare
Schemes :
- Universal
Immunisation Programme (UIP) for the control of
vaccine preventable diseases namely, diphtheria,
pertussis, neo-natal tetanus, tuberculosis,
poliomyelitis and measles.
- Oral Rehydration
Therapy (ORT) Programme for control of deaths due
to dehydration caused by diarrhoea.
- Prophylaxis Schemes
against nutritional anaemia among pregnant and
lactating mothers and against blindness due to
Vitmin A deficiency among children of under 5
years of age.
Child
Survival and Safe Motherhood (CSSM) Programme:
The CSSM
Programme, launched in 1992-93, is being implemented with
the financial assistance of World Bank and UNICEF and has
an outlay of Rs. 1125.5 crore over a seven year period.
The Programme has the following components :
- Sustaining and
strengthening the ongoing Immunisation, Oral
Rehydration Therapy (ORT) and Prophylaxis
Schemes;
- Improving maternal
care at community level by providing training to
the Traditional Birth Attendants (TBAs) and
disposable delivery kits to the pregnant women;
- Expanding, in a
phased manner, the programme for control of Acute
Respiratory Infections (ARI) for children below 5
years of age; and
- Setting up in a
phased manner, a network of sub-district level
First Referral Units (FRUs) for improving
emergency obstetric care in the States of Assam,
Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan and
Uttar Pradesh.
Universal
Immunisation Programme (UIP)
Universal
Immunisation Programme (UIP), launched in 1985, has been
declared as one of the Technology Missions in 1986, as a
part of the overall national strategy to bring down
infant and maternal mortality in the country. At the
beginning of the Programme in 1985-86, vaccine coverage
levels ranged between 29 per cent for BCG and 41 per cent
for DPT. During 1995-96 (upto February 1996) coverage
levels ranged from 67 per cent for TT (PW) to 84 per cent
for BCG.
Surveillance
of Vaccine Preventable Diseases :
A reliable
surveillance system has been developed. The immediate
reporting of cases of neo-natal tetanus and poliomyelitis
has been made mandatory. There has been a significant
decline in the incidence of these diseases.
Impact
on Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) :
The effective impact
of the programme is reflected in the significant drop in
the infant mortality rate from 129 in 1976 to 74 in 1993.
In the States of Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa and
Rajasthan, the IMR has steadily come down.
Oral
Rehydration Therapy (ORT) for Diarrhoea Control Among
Children
The Oral Rehydration Therapy Programme had started in
1986-87 in a phased manner with the objective to prevent
diarrhoea associated deaths in children due to
dehydration. Diarrhoea still remains one of the leading
causes of death among children under 5 years. Oral
Rehydration Salts (ORS) has been used as a drug of choice
for proper case management of diarrhoea cases.
Prophylaxis
Schemes
Anaemia
Prevention and Control among Pregnant Women:
Anaemia, accounts for
20 per cent of the maternal deaths in the country. It is
one of the major causes of maternal mortality and is an
aggravating factor in hemorrhage, toxemia and sepsis. The
CSSM programme, therefore, has prioritised pregnant women
for Iron and Folic Acid (IFA) administration. During
1994-95, 208.00 lakh (85.8 per cent) pregnant women were
provided with the recommended dosage of IFA tablets.
Prevention
and Control of Vitamin A deficiency among Children :
Vitamin A deficiency,
which can lead to blindness, is widely prevalent in the
country, especially among the pre-school children. The
CSSM programme sought to administer six-monthly doses of
concentrated Vitamin-A to the children between 1 to 3
years of age. During 1994-95, 149.8 lakh (72.6 per cent)
infants were administered the measles-linked dose while
the DPT/OPV booster linked dose was administered to 98.6
lakh (54.8 per cent) children in the age group of 1-2
years.
Essential
Maternal Care Dais Training, Their Reporting Fees
And Disposable Delivery Kits for Pregnant Women:
The data for 1992
indicates that the proportion of deliveries attended by
untrained hands was high, particularly in the rural
areas. With the goal to achieve 100 per cent deliveries
by trained personnel the CSSM Programme accords a high
priority to speed up the training of Traditional Birth
Attendants (Dais). An amount of Rs. 7.50 crore has been
allocated during 1994-95 for 500/250 Dais per district.
The reporting fee offered to the Dais has also been
enhanced from Rs. 3.00 per case to Rs. 10.00 per case.
There is a provision for the supply of disposable
delivery kits containing essential items for safe and
hygienic delivery to pregnant women.
First
Referral Units (FRUs) for Emergency Obstetric Care:
Upgrading of rural
health facilities, with a post of a gynaecologist, an
operation theatre, essential equipments and skill based
training is being undertaken in certain districts. Easier
accessibility to adequate medical care is essential for
an effective referral system and for promoting timely and
early referral.
Pulse
Polio Immunization (PPI)
Government of
India decided to implement the strategy of National
Immunization Days i.e Pulse Polio Immunization, beginning
in 1995 to achieve polio eradication by the year 2000A.D.
In the first phase, Government decided to observe Pulse
Polio Immunizaiton on the two fixed days, on these two
days, Oral Polio Vaccine (OPV) was given to all children
of 0 to 3 years of age in the entire country regardless
of previous immunization. 8.7 crore children in the
country, including 7.9 crore in the age group 0-3 years,
were given a dose of Oral Polio Vaccine in the country on
9 December 1995 and equal number of 9.3 crore children
including 8.5 crore in the age group 0-3 years were given
a dose of Oral Polio Vaccine in the second round on 20
January 1996.
The public response to Pulse Polio Immunisation was
overwhelming. Mothers made a beeline for the immunization
posts since early in the morning. One hundred per cent of
the target was achieved.
PPI was the biggest public health intervention ever to be
carried out in India. All departments of the government
and non-governmental organisations successfully
coordinated and cooperated to achieve full coverage.
The second phase of Pulse Polio Immunization was
implemented on two days i.e. on 7 December 96 and 18
January, 1997.
Rural
Health Services
Several programmes
and schemes are implemented under the Minimum Needs
Programme to provide primary health care relevant to the
actual needs of the community in the rural areas. The
status of Sub-Centres, Primary Health Centres (PHCs) and
Community Health Centres (CHCs) under the Minimum Needs
Programme is as follows :
Sub-Centre
:
A Sub-Centre is
established on the basis of one Centre for every 5,000
population in the plain areas and for every 3,000
population in the hilly and tribal areas. There were
1,31,900 sub-centres functiong during the year 1995-96.
Primary
Health Centres (PHCs) :
Primary Health Centres
are established on the basis of one PHC for every 30,000
population in the plain areas and for every 20,000
population in hilly, tribal and backward areas. The
number of PHCs functioning in the country was 21,693
during the year 1995-96.
Community
Health Centres (CHCs) :
Rural hospitals, with
specialist facilities were established by upgrading PHCs
having 30 beds to cover a population of 80,000 - 1.20
lakh. In 1995-96 the number of functioning CHCs was
2,385.
Other
Causes of Disabilities
Apart from major
causes of disabilities like blindness, leprosy, polio,
iodine deficiency there are other causes which have also
received attention from various agencies including :
Genetic
Causes of Birth Defects
Abnormalities of
structure, function and body chemistry result in
physical, sensory or mental disabilities are caused by
heredity factors, apart from environmental interference
with a childs development before, during and after
birth. Heredity information, containing characteristics
(including defects) is passed on from parents to a child.
Many genetic disorders can be traced to modes of
inheritance such as Huntington Disease (progressive
deterioration of the central nervous system) or Dwarfism
(retardation of bone growth). Some defects like
Downs Syndrome (popularly known as Mongolism) is
present at birth and is the result of chromosomal
imbalance or an error occuring during the process of cell
formation at the time of conception. This is not a
"heredity condition" in the sense that it is
not transferred from parents defective genes. It is
essentially a random mistake and can happen to anyone,
but women over 35 years are at a greater risk than
younger mothers.
Many genetic diseases are due to abnormal enzymes.
Experts in human genetics and medicine maintain that
there are over 3200 causes of heredity disorders and in
at least half of them these causes can be identified.
Advancement in this extremely important field has helped
to identify foetus at risk. On the basis of such a
diagnosis recommendation can be made for the termination
of pregnancy. With the help of the techniques of genetic
counselling parents can be forewarned. Without such
expert advice there is a risk that all or several
children in a family would either be born with
disabilities or would become disabled as they get older.
Genetic counselling, genetic engineering and many other
new techniques now can identify preconditions responsible
for inherited disabilities. Such breakthrough have the
potential of making an appreciable impact on the
incidence of disability. Such expertise is as yet,
available only at selected institutions in large cities
and outside the knowledge and reach of ordinary people.
There is a definite need to establish a network of
services accessible to couples at risk and to
paramedical, medical and health service personnel.
Regular training and orientation of medical, health and
social welfare staff is needed to advise the parents.
Fluorosis
A number of
diseases can result from unsafe drinking water, fluorosis
is one among these. It causes health problems such as
stomach disorders, discolouration and loss of teeth, pain
and stiffness in joints, backbone as well as muscles and
even results in crippling a patient on a permanent basis.
According to a report published by Government of
Indias National Technology Mission on Drinking
water, "In India today, millions of men, women and
children are crippled and lead a vegetative life due to
fluorosis".
For want of any proper survey the number of people who
are suffering, or have been crippled, as a result of
fluorosis is not precisely known. However, it has been
roughly estimated that about 25 million people in the
country, living in 150 districts in 15 States, are
seriously affected. These 15 endemic States are : Delhi,
Jammu and Kashmir, Kerala, Orissa, Bihar, Haryana,
Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Punjab, Andhra
Pradesh, Gujarat, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Uttar
Pradesh.
According to the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) (1991),
excess flouride intake can be prevented by
non-consumption of high fluoride water and other food
items and by increasing the intake of Calcium and Vitamin
C which help in fighting against the harmful effects of
fluoride.
Lathyrism
Lathyrism is a
type of paralysis in the lower limbs. It is prevalent in
Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Maharashtra,
Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and also in parts of West Bengal.
This is caused due to excess consumption of lathyrus
sativus (Khesari Dal) and is irreversible and incurable.
The disease occurs in four stages. The first stage is
characterised by an awkward gait and the patient can walk
without the help of a stick. The disease then advance to
on-stick stage because of muscular stiffness, then due to
excessive bending of knees and crossing legs, the
individual is reduced to the crawling stage and
eventually he becomes totally crippled. About four per
cent of the total population is estimated to be affected
by lathyrism in the affected areas.
The consumers of khesari dal are, of necessity, poverty
stricken agricultural labourers and people belonging to
socially disadvantaged and deprived groups. They have to
depend on this dal for their survival and normally
receive it as part of their wages from landlords. Except
Bihar, Madhya Pradesh and West Bengal all State
governments have prohibited the use of such dal for human
consumption. The State Government of U.P. has even banned
the cultivation of Khesari dal. Despite these government
efforts and warnings about the risk, the dal is still
being cultivated and is being consumed. The concerned
government departments have drawn up value suggestions to
reduce the danger of Khesari dal including steeping
process and par boiling process which
remove or reduce the poisonous substances in the dal.
Some low-toxin varieties of the seeds have also been
developed. Systematic research has resulted in setting up
of a detoxifying plant in Rewa. However, the problems of
cultivation and consumption of Khesari dal causing
lathyrism continue.
Casualties
from Accidents
All human
activitiesoccupational, recreational, domestic or
transportation are subject to accident risk and
therefore sustained efforts should be made to reduce
accidents, particularly those resulting in partial or
total disability or death. Owing to the rapid changes in
the mode of living as well as the environment in India
the rate of fatal and non-fatal accidents is on increase.
It is extremely complex to calculate the economic loss
which results from avoidable events. Accidents are caused
by falls, inside or outside home, burns, drowning,
transport (railways, road traffic, air travel, travel
marine), poisonous gases, poisons, dangerous drugs, riots
and violence, etc.
As per NSSO survey results, three to four per cent of
visual disability as well as speech and hearing
disability and 22 per cent of locomotor disabilities are
due to injuries.
The Research Division of the National Society for Equal
Opportunities for the Handicapped (NASEOH), Bombay, has
estimated that about 25,000 industrial workers acquire
permanent disability every year due to industrial
accidents.
According to a publication entitled Statistics of Road
Accidents in India (1983-1992), by the Ministry of
Surface Transport, Government of India, 54,100 persons
were killed and 2,44,100 persons were injured in road
accidents in India in 1990 alone. There has been nearly
four times increase in the number of deaths as well as
injuries during 1970-1990. According to a guessetimate,
nearly half a million persons acquire disability due to
transportation accidents every year in India. Ownership
of motorised vehicles in India is nearly one per cent of
the worlds vehicle population, yet its share of
road accidents in nearly six per cent.
Agricultural accidents could be largely prevented by
redesigning the existing machines, like threshers and
chaff cutters and also by stricter implementation of the
Dangerous Machines Act and Bureau of Indian Standards
(BIS) for the machines as well as by educating public
with the help of print and electronic media. Accidents
will always occur but their frequency and severity can be
kept in check.
Nutritional
Causes
Nutrition is
essential for the body, its growth, health, maintenance
and reproduction. Adequate food supply ultimately
determines the nutritional status of an individual as
well as the society in which he lives. Malnutrition
adversely affects health, damages the supply of energy to
the body and disrupts countless chemical reactions in the
body. Nutrition is composed of energy factors such as
calories, carbohydrates, proteins, fats and vitamins. Any
imbalance or starvation in the supply, quality and
quantity of these results in malnutrition and deficiency,
often causing irreversible or permanent disabilities,
visual impairment and mental retardation.
In recent years there has been a significant drop in the
population below poverty line (56.8 per cent in 1960 to
29.0 per cent in 1987), but about 250 million out of 930
million still suffer from varying degrees of malnutrition
in India.
According to the National Nutrition Policy, published in
1993 by the Department of Women and Child Development,
Government of India, 43.8 per cent children were
estimated to suffer from severe malnutrition in 1989-90,
although there had been a decline during 1975-90 of 3.75
per cent in moderate malnutrition and 6.3 per cent in
severe malnutrition.
Combating malnutrition has been one of the objectives of
the Indian Government and along with overall rise in food
production and reduction in poverty level in the country,
specific interventions have been planned and implemented.
One such major step is the scheme of Integrated Child
Development Services (ICDS) which has supplementary
nutrition as its main component. ICDS had covered nearly
3000 blocks - roughly 60 per cent of the country by end
of 1992-93. The Beneficiaries of this programme are
children below six years of age, pregnant and lactating
mothers and women in 15-44 age-groups.
Some other programmes to tackle the problem of
malnutrition are Special Nutrition Programme, Balwadi
Nutrition Programme, Wheat-based Supplementary Nutrition
Programme and Mid-day Meals Programmes in certain States.
International agencies such as Care-International and
USAID also have programmes to tackle this problem.
The deficiency of vitamin A and protein energy
malnutrition are major causes of childhood blindness. A
Prophylaxis Programme Against Blindness due to Vitamin A
deficiency was started by the Government in 1970. Under
this programme children in 1-5 age-group are given an
oral dose of 0.2 million IU of vitamin A in oil, every
six months. The programme covers 30 million out of 80
million children in the target group. Over the years
significant reduction in childhood blindness has been
reported. Effective implementation of the programme
continues.
In order to strengthen the thrust the Government of India
have now adopted a National Nutrition Policy to cover the
multiple aspects of nutritional programmes. Under the
policy, National Nutrition Council and an
Inter-ministerial Coordination Committee have been set
up. Linkages between the food policy, the agricultural
policy, the health policy, the education policy, the
rural development programmes and the nutrition policy are
established to effectively tackle the problems of
malnutrition.
Ante-natal,
Natal and Post-natal Causes
The 7th Plan had
provided for a trained birth attendant for every 1000
population in 5,800,000 villages in India, and thus
trained 5.8 lakh dais in the country (M.R. in India, A
Contemporary Scene, NIMH). Low birth weight increases the
risk of hazards in development for infants and children.
One third of the babies born in India are of low birth
weight. Early marriage, frequent pregnancies, poor
nutrition and illiteracy are a few of the contributing
factors. This vicious cycle, created by such factors
results in harmful affects in adulthood and also in the
next generation. Most government hospitals have post
partum centres, yet women deliver their babies with the
help of untrained dais. Many do not receive immunisation
and ante/pre/post natal care. In Rajasthan, 67 per cent
of mothers did not receive any antenatal care
either at home or outside. (National Family Health
Survey).
Safe motherhood can prevent a number of disabilities,
such as vision impairment, cerebral palsy, mental
retardation and hearing impairment. There is a programme
to provide iron and folic acid to the pregnant mothers.
Although there is a programme of providing a trained
mid-wife for every 5000 population, due to the inadequacy
of training and lack of confidence of the people in the
trained dais most of the deliveries in rural areas are
still attended by traditional dais, who, by and large, do
a good job but are unable to take care of the
complications, if and when they arise. The Government of
India has taken up a programme of Social Safety Net
Scheme, with the assistance from the World Bank, under
which, facilities at the Primary Health Centres will be
upgraded in 90 weak districts in the country.
These facilities would include labour rooms, equipments,
trained staff, regular water, electricity availability
and facilities for education and information. The mothers
would be encouraged with institutional deliveries and
safe motherhood. The scheme has been taken up from
1992-93. The scheme is well-intentioned, no doubt. The
results, however, are yet to be seen with the coverage
not being universal.
Efforts
Aimed at Prevention
According to WHO,
the main causes of disability in India are INFECTION,
NEGLECT and IGNORANCE. Among the underlying causes are
low socio-economic conditions, inadequate health care and
nutrition.
It is estimated that in the urban slums, 15 million
children live in conditions of acute deprivation with
inadequate access to basic health care, nutrition and
safe drinking water (National Institute of Urban
Affairs). Millions are affected by tetanus and have been
disabled due to preventable causes and nutritional
deficiencies, polio and acute respiratory infections.
Present studies reveal differences in the disability
prevalence rates between urban and rural areas with
greater disparities for those disabilities which are
nutrition related (55 per cent visual disability and 42
per cent for hearing disability).
The first National Family Health Survey conducted by the
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare presented a dismal
picture of malnutrition. Over 50 per cent of children
under the age of 5 in several States had severe
malnourishment. Only Kerala had shown malnutrition levels
for children under five as less than 30 per cent. The
survey had also revealed that the health objectives for
women and children have not been achieved.
Immunisation
India has one seventh
of the worlds population and one third of the
disabled population of the world. Diseases which should
have been eradicated by effective and total immunisation
are still crippling or killing a large number of
children. To note an example, a study of 15 class A, B
and C cities in Rajasthan revealed that the percentage of
fully immunised children in Jaipur, Jodhpur and Kota was
only 21 per cent. Fully immunised children at two years
of age were below 50 per cent in A, 60 per cent in B and
53 per cent in C towns. The coverage was better in
smaller towns than in the larger cities.
The cold chain required by the live vaccine from the
point of manufacture to the ultimate user-child, often
becomes ineffective, particularly in rural areas when the
cold chain breaks down and polio cases emerge even after
vaccination (S.S. Varma). Between 3-5 lakh children are
affected by polio every year. Government data shows
14,000 new cases in 1989 (National Covention).
The National Pusle Polio initiative launched in 1994 is
an effort to prevent further incidence of it and is being
implemented countrywide. The aim is to ensure that every
child is given two doses of polio vaccine within the
specified period.
Vitamin
A
Despite the focus
of preventive measures of the maternal and child health
programmes, during past quarter of a century on Vitamin
A, about 15,000 children go blind each year due to its
deficiency (National Covention). The National Nutrition
Monitoring Bureau has reported that prevalence of vitamin
A deficiency in pre-school children is over 10 per cent
in many states. The overall achievement of Vitamin A
prophylaxis is 78.4 per cent. Vitamin A deficiency is
also linked to child mortality and morbidity. Studies
have shown that the mortality rate increases four times
in children even with mild signs of Vitamin A deficiency.
Complications due to measles, incidence of diarrhoea and
respiratory diseases are also higher. Infections become
more severe. Most of such ill-effects are because of the
faulty distribution and monitoring system. Most children
who suffer from Vitamin A Deficiency belong to the less
privileged socio-economic groups. Specially affected are
the urban poor because of non-availability of Vitamin A
rich foods as they are seasonal as well outside their
purchasing power. Vitamin A deficiency is also
precipitated by a range of infections and illnesses
including diarrhoea.
Integrated
Child Development Services (ICDS)
The ICDS programme
through an integrated package of services was instituted
in response to the need to break the vicious cycle of
malnutrition, disease/infection, resultant disability and
mortality in the crucial early years of an infants
life. In 20 years in the service of the pre-school child
and the mother, the ICDS programme reached out to 3.8
million expectant and nursing mothers and adolescent
girls, 17.8 million children (under 6) through nearly
300,000 anganwadi centres. Of these 10.2 million children
(3-6 age-group) participated in centre based pre-school
education activities.
The ICDS network consists of 3907 projects, covering
nearly 70 per cent of the countrys community
development blocks and 260 urban slum pockets. The
population coverage through the anganwadi is
approximately 1,000 in rural and urban areas and 700 in
the tribal belts (Department of Women and Child, HRD
Ministry).
The current focus of the ICDS is on reducing malnutrition
in the young child, using immunisation contact points and
mobilisation of womens community groups, promoting
complementary feeding and Oral Rehydration Therapy, thus
ensuring the childs right to healthy development.
Inspite of the conviction of the policy and the planners,
children with disabilities remain marginalised in the
ICDS programme and its activities. A sizeable number of
children often remain undetected in the early stages.
Possibilities of prevention/detection recede further when
they are not taken to the health centres for
immunisation. There is very little co-ordination between
health and ICDS functionaries leading to sporadic efforts
at immunisation, health checkups or educational
activities.
There is no integration in the anganwadis and the
disabled children grow up in an environment indifferent
to their real needs. The anganwadi worker has limited
understanding, skill and knowledge in arranging
pre-school activities and her limited sensitivity is
unable to integrate the disabled children in the
pre-school programme. Due to its reliance on voluntary
efforts, ICDS has been able to keep down its
implementational costs but the low honorarium paid to the
anganwadi workers is a major impediment to sustaining
motivation. They feel overburdened with responsibilities
and tend to concentrate on services that are more closely
monitored, such as supplementary nutrition distribution,
immunisation, etc. A recent study of the National
Institute of Nutrition indicated that 40-50 per cent of
anganwadi workers in Andhra Pradesh could not distinguish
backward children from normal with respect to their
psychological development.
In the three month training of anganwadi workers, only
two days are alloted to orientation on symptoms of
disability, suitable play activities, availability of
aids and appliances for them. However, the present
arrangements of training remains localized to the areas
which are serviced by the 11 institutes that handle such
training. Disability training has been introduced into
the second phase of the three phase sandwich programme.
Bringing adolescent girls into the ambit of the service
delivery system ensure that the prospective mothers are
nutritonally sustained to deliver healthy babies, have
learned appropriate mother-care skills and knowledge to
meet the nurture needs to prevent disability (Samadhan
News, April-June, 1995).
Delivery
of Services
India has built up
an impressive infrastructure of primary health care in
terms of a network of health centres, hospitals and
trained personnel. Sadly, the Primary Health Centres
(PHCs) are in a deplorable state, a majority of them
without essential medicines and trained staff (Minister
for Health, Mr. A. R. Antulay).
The emphasis is on infrastructure development rather than
on quality services. Even in urban areas where hospitals
and health centres are within easier reach than in the
rural areas, the basic health care is not provided as was
indicated by the recent outbreak of plague and dengue
epidemics in several cities.
The health system continues to emphasise the curative
rather than the preventive measures. The hospitals are
ill equipped to deal with the multifaceted problems of
disability. Rehabilitation services are confined to
medical aspects in the district hospitals. There is a
shortage of E.N.T. experts and speech pathologists, and
no genetic counseling or referral services are provided
(S.S. Varma).
Family Welfare centres and health posts to improve the
outreach of primary health care at all government
hospitals, recommended by the Krishnan Committee, are not
enough to cope with the growing needs of the rising
population. In the urban areas, only 1,291 family welfare
centres and 936 health posts in 10 States exist (Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare).
There is an urgent need for the convergence of services
through co-ordinated efforts of the different agencies
involved. The 73rd and 74th Amendment Act, places on
decentralised elected bodies, with representation from
the community, the responsibility to prepare development
plans, and to deal with related subjects such as health,
social welfare, child development and women. This
procedure should benefit disabled children as well.
However, operational mechanisms need to be developed to
evolve a system of effective co-ordination and the
convergence of services between the Ministries of Health,
Education and Welfare.
The Government of India is making efforts to improve the
situation and to provide better services to the disabled
through a range of programmes/actions/schemes. The India
Population Projects in four metropolitan cities aim to
strengthen basic health care services to women and
children by establishing functional linkages with other
government programmes such as the ICDS. The formulation
of a National Rehabilitation Programme called for greater
involvement of NGOs in the screening, detection,
assessment, training, management and care, vocational
training and job placement of people with disabilities,
trained rehabilitation workers attached with the primary
health centres.
|